Industry warns UK pension value ratings may favor forecasts over

The UK government’s Value for Money (VfM) framework for defined contribution (DC) pensions has faced strong criticism from industry experts, even as regulators finalize rules to evaluate and rate schemes based on performance, costs, and service quality. The system covers both contract-based and trust-based DC models, assigning a color-coded rating—ranging from red for poor value to dark green for top performers—and mandates the closure of underperforming schemes under the Pension Schemes Act. Despite years of drafting and consultation, significant concerns remain about how the framework will function in practice.
One of the most disputed aspects is the inclusion of forward-looking performance metrics in VfM assessments. While regulators introduced these to encourage long-term planning, industry respondents argue they risk skewing results by overemphasizing projections instead of actual outcomes. The Society of Pension Professionals (SPP) has cautioned that without strict limits, schemes could manipulate forecasts, particularly those with heavy exposure to private markets, to create an overly optimistic impression. The group recommends capping these metrics at 30% of a scheme’s overall rating, citing potential conflicts with the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) Consumer Duty, which requires fair treatment of members.
Ruari Grant, head of policy at TPT Retirement Solutions, described the approach as fundamentally flawed. “Without the right guardrails, it’s all too easy to paint an overly optimistic picture of returns on some pensions, particularly those with exposure to more opaque private markets… We don’t think forward-looking metrics belong anywhere near a genuine value-for-money assessment, not least because we think there’s direct tension with the FCA’s own Consumer Duty,” he said.
Grant added that schemes cannot be left to effectively mark their own homework, particularly when considering the current dispersion in member outcomes, and the commercial consequences that will flow from a VfM assessment. He stated that assessments must be driven by objective evidence of member value rather than subjective interpretation or narrative.
Delays and Early Scrutiny Risks
Implementation timing has also become a point of contention. The government postponed the first reporting period until 2028, with smaller schemes exempt until 2029, and delayed regulatory consequences, such as closing schemes to new members, for the initial year. However, providers warn that commercial and reputational damage could still occur before the framework is fully operational. Kate Smith, head of pensions at Aegon, noted that even without formal penalties, published ratings will face intense public scrutiny. “This could be made worse if it turns out that there’s a lack of consistency in how trustees and providers have interpreted their VfM input data, which will influence the comparator data, and how default arrangements are assessed against this,” she said.
Related Post: UK pension funds must move beyond size to smarter investing
The Pensions Administration Standards Association has urged regulators to treat the first year as a testing phase, allowing schemes to refine data collection and governance before public assessments. Emma Furlonger, managing director of workplace and retail intermediary at Standard Life, emphasized that the framework must prioritize metrics that are meaningful, comparable, and actionable, not merely bureaucratic. “In our view, the first year should operate as a genuine dry run, giving schemes, trustees, providers and regulators the opportunity to test data, address inconsistencies and build confidence in the methodology before ratings and assessments are made public,” she said. Renny Biggins, head of policy at the Investing and Savings Alliance, agreed, stressing that regulators and industry must align on a unified approach before data becomes public.
Innovation vs. Standardization Tradeoffs
Experts also warn that the framework could unintentionally suppress innovation. Mark Futcher, head of DC at Howden, cited Australia’s experience, where similar rules led to schemes adopting narrow investment strategies at the expense of long-term outcomes. “The design of the framework will be critical. There is a fine balance, which the DWP must tread, between increasing transparency and creating incentives that unintentionally encourage schemes to converge on similar investment approaches,” he said. Anthony Ellis, head of DC trust consulting at Hymans Robertson, added that the government must avoid a rigid, one-size-fits-all approach, which could disadvantage schemes catering to unique member needs or retirement strategies.
Helen Forrest Hall, chief strategy officer at the Pensions Management Institute, pointed out that members prioritize whether their pension is effective over financial jargon. “We are in real danger of losing the wood for the trees. Members want to know if they have invested in a good or a poor pension product. The framework needs to be able to answer that question without members having to go to night school to learn financial figures for non-financial people,” she said. Louise Davey of the Independent Governance Group stressed that VfM extends beyond investment performance to include service quality, member understanding, and retirement options.
Pushing Forward Despite Flaws
Despite criticisms, most agree the VfM framework’s core objective, improving transparency and outcomes for savers, remains valid. Helen Ball, partner at Sackers, urged regulators to finalize requirements promptly so schemes can prepare. Patrick Heath-Lay, CEO of People’s Partnership, called for close collaboration between regulators and industry to build confidence in the system.
The framework’s scope has expanded to address a critical oversight: decumulation, or how savers convert pension pots into retirement income. Industry groups have repeatedly urged regulators to incorporate decumulation metrics into VfM assessments, arguing that a scheme’s value depends not only on accumulation, how much is saved, but also on how easily members can access funds in retirement.
